Angi vs Thumbtack for pros: how do you pay for leads?

The short answer

With Angi vs Thumbtack for pros, the main difference you can check is how open the pricing is. Thumbtack publishes how lead prices, budgets and refunds work. Angi reports pay-per-lead alongside advertising and memberships, and you’ll need to confirm its terms directly. Test either on a small budget, and judge by cost per booked job. We sell local SEO pages, so weigh our view accordingly.

Reviewed by Anubhav Gupta, Bespoke Devs · Updated

Angi vs Thumbtack for pros, side by side

This comes from each company’s own published pages and filings. We haven’t tested either as a paying pro.

CompareAngiThumbtack
What counts as a leadA connection between a consumer and a pro resulting from a service requestA customer who contacts you directly, matched to your job preferences
Can one request reach several pros?Yes: Angi says one request can produce multiple leadsCustomers can contact several pros, and unhired customers may appear as Opportunities
How you’re chargedIncludes pay-per-lead, contracted advertising and membershipsDirect leads are billed automatically at the price you’ve set
Spending controlCheck current terms with AngiA weekly budget. New leads stop when you hit it, until Monday
Optional outreachCheck current termsOpportunities: charged only if you reach out and the customer responds
RefundsCheck current termsPublished policy, with requests within 45 days, at Thumbtack’s discretion
Stated directionPlans to offer a choice of paying per lead, per appointment or per job wonCheck current terms

Terms change often and can vary by trade or market. Confirm them with each company before you spend.

What each does better

Angi may suit you if

  • You want more than leads, such as contracted advertising or a membership
  • You want to compare several ways of paying
  • You’d rather pay per appointment or per job won, once Angi offers that in your market
  • Homeowners in your area use it

Thumbtack may suit you if

  • You want to set your own lead prices
  • You want a firm weekly spending cap
  • You want to read refund rules before you start
  • You’d like to pick which unhired customers to contact

Angi or Thumbtack: how to test them

A fair test of Angi vs Thumbtack for pros starts with checking that each one works for your trade and country. Then read the current terms and run a small, time-limited test. Keep a simple sheet showing every lead, what it cost, whether you reached the customer, and whether it booked. Include the time you spend chasing leads, as that’s a real cost.

These numbers are made up, to show the sum. Say you spend $1,200 on 40 leads and 8 book. That’s $30 a lead, and $150 per booked job. If your average job leaves $400 profit, that works. If it leaves $100, it doesn’t, however cheap the lead looks.

How your own site reduces the dependence

Lead platforms have a real strength: they can bring enquiries quickly, with no wait for search rankings. If you need work this month, that matters, and a website won’t do the same thing. Local SEO takes months, and results aren’t guaranteed.

The trouble is that you’re renting access. If prices go up or the rules change, your options are limited. Your own Business Profile, reviews and website work differently: they stay yours, and a lead that finds you there has no fee attached.

So treat your website as a slow way to bring down what you pay per job. Using the example above, each job that comes directly through your own pages is one you didn’t pay $150 for. Give repeat customers your own number too, so they don’t need to find you through a platform again. The lead channels guide shows how to compare all of these.

Common questions

  1. Don’t assume so. Angi says one service request can produce several leads, and Thumbtack customers can contact more than one pro. Reply quickly, and ask each company how a given lead is shared.

  2. Yes, but start with one so that your tracking stays clear. Keep whichever brings booked jobs at a profit.

  3. Thumbtack publishes a refund policy with a 45-day window and specific qualifying cases, at its discretion. For Angi, ask before you sign, and get the answer in writing.

  4. We haven’t covered it here. Check with Angi how any older HomeAdvisor account or product applies today.

  5. Only if the numbers say so. If a platform brings profitable jobs, keep it. Compare your cost per booked job on each channel.

Keep reading

Free audit

Find the local pages your website is missing.

We review your website, services and service areas, then show you which pages to build first and what may block indexing.

No obligation. Response within 24 hours.