SEO agency vs in house SEO: when should you stop outsourcing?

The short answer

SEO agency vs in house SEO mostly depends on your size. Most small local businesses don’t have enough work for a full-time hire, so outsourcing usually costs less. Bringing SEO in-house makes sense when you have many locations, steady content needs, and someone who can manage it. We’re an outside provider, so weigh our view accordingly.

Reviewed by Anubhav Gupta, Bespoke Devs · Updated

SEO agency vs in house SEO, side by side

CompareSEO agencyIn house SEO
How you payA project fee or monthly feeSalary, on-costs and tools
Range of skillsUsually several peopleDepends on one person, at first
Knows your businessHas to learn it, and you have to explainSees jobs and customers every day
Access to jobs and photosHas to askClose at hand
FocusShared with other clientsOnly yours
If it’s not workingEnd the contractHarder, and slower to change
If the person leavesThe agency replaces themThe work stops until you rehire

General patterns. Agencies and employees vary a lot.

Which one fits you

Stay with an agency if

  • You have one or a few locations
  • There isn’t a full role’s worth of work
  • Nobody in your business can manage an SEO hire
  • You only need occasional projects

Bring SEO in-house if

  • You have many locations with steady work
  • You’re already paying enough to cover a salary
  • You publish content all the time
  • You have a marketing manager who can direct the role

A sum to help you decide

To run the SEO agency vs in house SEO sum, start with what each costs in a year. These numbers are made up, to show the method. Say a marketing hire would cost your business $5,000 a month with on-costs and tools. That’s $60,000 a year. If you pay an agency $1,500 a month, that’s $18,000 a year.

At those numbers, the agency is cheaper unless the hire also takes over other paid work, such as ads, email or a part-time marketing role you’d otherwise fund. So don’t compare just the fee with the salary. Add up everything the person would replace, then add the time you’d spend managing them.

Remember the risk, too. One person can’t cover content, technical work, reporting and reviews equally well, and a junior hire without direction can drift.

Signs it’s time to stop outsourcing

  • You keep paying for things your team could doSuch as posting updates, replying to reviews or uploading job photos.
  • Your agency keeps asking for informationAnd good ideas die because nobody in your business can supply details.
  • The fee has grown to match a salaryDo the sum above with real figures.
  • You’ve got steady content to publishNew branches, new services or frequent local jobs to write about.

The middle option

You don’t have to pick one for everything. A staff member or owner can handle everyday things like replying to reviews and adding photos to your Business Profile, while an outside specialist handles defined projects such as a technical audit or a set of local pages. For a small business, this often costs far less than either a retainer or a hire. It only works if someone really does the everyday part.

Before you decide, ask a provider or job candidate the questions Google suggests. These cover examples of previous work, experience in your industry, and how they measure success. Google also warns against anyone promising first place in search results, and that applies to outsourcing and in-house SEO alike.

Common questions

  1. For everyday tasks, yes. For strategy and technical work, they’ll need support from someone experienced, at least at the start. Otherwise you may not know if the work is any good.

  2. Your website, domain, content, Business Profile, analytics and Search Console should all stay in your name. Check this before you sign anything, and again before you leave.

  3. That’s often the next step before a hire. Our [agency vs freelancer guide](/lead-channels/seo-agency-vs-freelancer) covers that decision.

  4. When nobody in your business will answer questions or supply job details. The outside team will end up writing vague pages, whatever you pay them.

Keep reading

Free audit

Find the local pages your website is missing.

We review your website, services and service areas, then show you which pages to build first and what may block indexing.

No obligation. Response within 24 hours.