SEO agency vs freelancer: who should you hire?

The short answer

SEO agency vs freelancer depends on how much help you need. A good freelancer often costs less and gives you direct access to the person doing the work. An agency usually offers more skills and cover. Whichever you pick, avoid anyone guaranteeing rankings. We offer fixed-price local page systems, so weigh our view accordingly.

Reviewed by Anubhav Gupta, Bespoke Devs · Updated

SEO agency vs freelancer, side by side

CompareFreelancer or consultantAgency
Who does the workUsually the person you hiredA team, so ask who
Range of skillsDepends on the personUsually broader
If someone is awayWork may pauseOthers can usually cover
CostOften lowerOften higher, with more overhead
ContractOften flexibleSometimes a minimum term

General patterns. Individuals and agencies vary a lot.

Which one fits you

Choose a freelancer if

  • You have one business and a modest budget
  • You want to talk to the person doing the work
  • You have a specific problem to solve
  • You’ve found someone with local results to show

Choose an agency if

  • You need content, technical work and reporting together
  • You have several locations
  • You don’t want to depend on one person
  • You have the budget for ongoing work

Start by writing down the work

The easiest way to settle SEO agency vs freelancer is to list what you need done before you speak to anyone. If the list is short and one person could do it, such as fixing page titles and building a few local pages, a freelancer may be all you need. If it includes content, technical work, reporting and several locations at once, one person may struggle to cover it.

Then think about your own time. A freelancer may need you to make more of the decisions. An agency usually has someone managing the work, and you pay for that layer.

Whichever you choose, start small if you can. Give them a defined job with a clear end, such as a short audit or a handful of service pages. You’ll see how they communicate, whether they meet dates and how good the work is before you commit to anything ongoing.

What to ask either one

  • Show me local resultsAsk for examples like yours, and check that they’re real and recent.
  • What exactly will you do?Get specific deliverables, not just “monthly SEO”.
  • Who owns the work?Your website, content and profile access should stay yours.
  • How will we measure it?Look for calls, forms and bookings, not only rankings.
  • Do you guarantee rankings?If the answer is yes, be careful. Nobody controls Google.

Warning signs in either one

  • Vague reportsCharts of rankings and traffic, with no mention of calls or bookings, don’t show what you paid for.
  • Accounts in their nameIf the provider holds your website, profile or analytics in its own name, leaving gets hard. Keep them in yours.
  • A switch after the saleA senior person sells the work, and someone you’ve never met does it. Ask who’ll really be doing it.
  • A long term with no list of workSome minimum term can be fair. Being locked in without knowing what you’ll receive isn’t.

Common questions

  1. That usually makes sense once SEO is big enough to fill a full-time role. Most small local businesses don’t have enough steady work, so [SEO agency vs in house SEO](/lead-channels/seo-agency-vs-in-house) tends to matter later.

  2. A consultant is usually one experienced person who advises and may do some of the work. An agency is a team that usually delivers the work for you.

  3. It varies widely by location and scope. Compare what’s delivered, not just the price, and be wary of very cheap offers that promise guaranteed rankings.

  4. Yes. Keep your website, content and accounts in your own name, and ask for notes on the work done. Then a new provider can pick up without starting again.

  5. Ask which business the results came from, then look for yourself. Search for its services in its area, and ask if you can speak to the client. Old results, or results from a different kind of business, tell you less.

Keep reading

Free audit

Find the local pages your website is missing.

We review your website, services and service areas, then show you which pages to build first and what may block indexing.

No obligation. Response within 24 hours.