Yelp vs Google reviews: where should you focus?

The short answer

For Yelp vs Google reviews, most local businesses should focus on Google first. Google lets you ask customers for reviews, and says more reviews and positive ratings can help your local ranking. Yelp asks you not to request reviews at all. So actively collect reviews on Google, and keep your Yelp page accurate so that real reviews can build up there.

Reviewed by Anubhav Gupta, Bespoke Devs · Updated

Yelp vs Google reviews for a business owner

CompareGoogle reviewsYelp reviews
Can you ask for them?Yes, with a Google link or QR codeNo: Yelp says don’t ask anyone
Only asking happy customersNot allowed: no selective askingYelp says not to ask at all
Offering incentivesNot allowedNot allowed
FilteringRemoves content that breaks its policySoftware chooses which reviews to recommend. The rest don’t count in the rating or review count
Effect of askingAllowed, within the rulesMay hurt your rating and your placement in Yelp search
Link to your search visibilityGoogle says reviews can help local rankingAffects how you appear on Yelp

From each company’s own policies. Check them again before you change how you collect reviews.

Where to put your effort

Put most effort into Google if

  • Customers find you through Google Search or Maps
  • You want a system for asking after every job
  • You have few recent reviews
  • You aren’t sure yet where customers look

Give Yelp real attention if

  • Customers regularly tell you they found you on Yelp
  • You work in a trade or area where people check it
  • Your Yelp page shows wrong details
  • A rival’s Yelp presence is winning work you can measure

What Yelp does better

Yelp’s approach has a real point. It argues that asked-for reviews can be skewed, because businesses tend to ask customers they expect to be happy. Its software looks for conflicts of interest, solicited reviews and unreliable reviews, and it says nobody at Yelp can override those decisions. It also says advertisers and non-advertisers are treated exactly the same.

You can also read what’s been filtered, since not-recommended reviews stay available through a link at the bottom of the page. A reader who cares can look. Google’s rules are also strict, but it’s easier for an owner to build volume there, as asking is allowed.

Are Yelp or Google reviews more reliable?

We don’t have independent evidence that one is more reliable, and most claims on this come from people with something to sell. Both companies publish rules against fake and paid reviews, and both have to enforce them at scale. Read recent reviews on either, look for specific details, and be sceptical of very short or very similar ones.

The same goes for your own reviews. A few detailed, recent reviews from real customers tell a reader far more than a long list of “great service”.

A simple plan

You can work on Yelp vs Google reviews in the same week, as long as you keep their rules apart.

  1. This weekFix the basics on bothClaim your Google Business Profile and Yelp page. Check your name, phone number, hours and service area on each.
  2. Every jobAsk for a Google reviewSend your review link or show a QR code. Ask all customers, without any reward, and don’t pre-screen them for happiness.
  3. Every weekReply to reviewsGoogle suggests short, professional and personal replies, without generic thank-yous or promotional offers.
  4. For YelpLet them know you’re thereYelp suggests a “Find us on Yelp” sticker or sign. Don’t ask for a review, and don’t send a review request after a survey.
  5. Every monthAsk how customers found youIf Yelp keeps coming up, give it more time. If it never does, don’t.

Common questions

  1. No. A request that mentions Yelp goes against Yelp’s policy on asking. Send customers to Google only, and let Yelp reviews come by themselves.

  2. They’ve probably moved to the not-recommended section. Yelp’s software re-evaluates reviews over time. Those reviews remain available through a link on your page, but don’t count in your rating.

  3. Yelp says no. It states that advertising has no connection with how its software treats your reviews.

  4. No. Google strictly prohibits offering free or discounted goods or services for reviews, and Yelp bans this too. Yelp also notes it may be illegal, so check your local rules.

  5. No, so Yelp vs Google Maps reviews is the same comparison as this page. Google reviews are attached to your Business Profile, so the same reviews can appear on Search and Maps. Yelp reviews are separate, and sit on Yelp.

Keep reading

Free audit

Find the local pages your website is missing.

We review your website, services and service areas, then show you which pages to build first and what may block indexing.

No obligation. Response within 24 hours.